top of page

WE HAVE INVESTED IN GREAT TEACHERS. HAVE WE INVESTED ENOUGH IN GREAT LEADERS?

The Intrinsic Link Between Strategic Leadership
and Teacher Retention

Stephen Scott, ETHICLEAD Founder and Principal

Why the pathway from classroom excellence to strategic leadership deserves closer examination.

One of the characteristics of the teaching profession that has always interested me is the relatively continuous relationship many teachers have with the school environment. They begin school as children, progress through secondary education, complete university studies and, for many, return almost immediately to schools where they spend the remainder of their careers. This is neither criticism nor disadvantage in itself; it is simply a feature of the profession. Teachers develop extraordinary depth in areas such as pedagogy, curriculum, assessment, student development and classroom practice because their professional lives are deliberately shaped around education. The difficulty arises when we later ask these same people to assume increasingly complex leadership responsibilities without always providing an equally deliberate pathway for developing the capabilities those responsibilities require.

​

The transition often begins in middle leadership. An accomplished teacher becomes a head of department, curriculum leader, year level coordinator or takes on another position involving responsibility for the performance of other adults. The promotion is often entirely understandable because the individual has demonstrated professional competence, credibility and commitment. Yet the nature of their work has now fundamentally changed. Their success is no longer determined only by how effectively they teach, but increasingly by how effectively they lead others who teach. The Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership’s (AITSL’s) recent work on middle leadership acknowledges this transition very clearly, identifying aspiring, anointed and accidental pathways into leadership and noting that some leaders enter roles without formal preparation or before they feel ready. The new Australian Professional Standards for Middle Leaders similarly recognise that middle leadership requires distinct dispositions, knowledge and skills, including relational trust, self-reflection, solving complex problems, interpersonal courage, perseverance and resilience.

WHEN PROMOTION CHANGES THE JOB

This raises an important question about the way schools have traditionally developed leaders. If somebody demonstrates excellence as a teacher, we quite reasonably identify their potential for broader responsibility, but excellence within one professional domain should not automatically be interpreted as capability within another. Leading adults requires different skills from teaching students. Leaders must establish expectations, delegate effectively, conduct difficult conversations, manage conflict, influence peers, develop culture, make decisions under uncertainty, allocate resources and increasingly understand the relationship between their own area of responsibility and the strategic direction of the whole organisation. None of this diminishes the importance of teaching expertise. It simply recognises that promotion changes the nature of the capability required.

​

Over time, the same developmental pattern can continue. The successful middle leader becomes a deputy principal, head of school or member of the executive team before perhaps eventually becoming a principal. At each transition, the environment becomes more complex and the consequences of leadership decisions become more significant. The leader is progressively required to move beyond responsibility for teaching and learning into workforce strategy, finance, governance, compliance, risk, stakeholder engagement, organisational culture and long-term strategic direction. Yet there is no guarantee that their leadership development has progressed at the same rate as their positional authority. Indeed, AITSL has previously reported that Australia lacks a coordinated strategic approach to principal preparation and that 45 per cent of Australian principals reported receiving average or weak leadership training as part of their formal education.

KNOWING ISN'T THE SAME AS DOING

Many leaders recognise this gap themselves and invest heavily in their own development. Postgraduate qualifications such as a Master of Educational Leadership can provide valuable knowledge, introduce leadership theory and broaden understanding well beyond the classroom. This should be encouraged, but it also presents another distinction that I have explored through my work on Strategic Leadership Capability. Knowing something does not necessarily mean we are capable of consistently doing it. Leadership is behavioural, and behaviour develops through disciplined application in the environment within which leadership is actually exercised. A leader may understand theoretically how to delegate, manage underperformance, challenge assumptions or lead organisational change, yet still struggle to apply that understanding when confronted by difficult relationships, competing priorities, political pressure or an organisational culture that reinforces very different behaviours.

​

This is where the workplace becomes critically important. Professional development cannot be considered independently of the organisational environment into which people return. The Australian Council for Educational Research’s (ACER's) work on teacher professional development similarly argues that effective professional learning requires coherent structures and ongoing support rather than isolated training, and that school leadership and the local context materially influence whether new practices are successfully implemented. The same principle applies to leadership development. If somebody returns from a leadership program to an environment in which difficult conversations are routinely avoided, strategic decisions remain highly centralised, poor performance is tolerated, operational urgency continually overrides strategic priorities and positional authority substitutes for disciplined leadership, the opportunity to practise and embed different leadership behaviours becomes considerably more difficult.

LEARNING LEADERSHIP ON THE JOB

Perhaps, therefore, the problem is not that schools have failed to produce enough capable people. Schools are filled with extraordinarily capable people. The more confronting possibility is that we have historically relied too heavily upon promotion, experience and individual initiative to somehow convert those people into capable leaders. Leadership capability is then expected to emerge progressively through exposure to increasingly difficult roles rather than being deliberately developed through a coherent organisational system. Some people navigate this exceptionally well because of their personal qualities, mentors, opportunities and willingness to learn. Others struggle, not because they lack potential, but because the organisation has asked them to perform at a level for which they were never systematically prepared.

​

I also think we need to be careful about comparing leadership development within schools with leadership development in business, because each environment creates different pressures and develops different forms of resilience. A business owner may spend years dealing with commercial uncertainty, cash-flow pressure, competitive threats, unsuccessful investments and the continual requirement to generate the next source of revenue. These experiences can develop particular forms of judgement and resilience because the environment repeatedly demands them. Teachers develop different capabilities through continual exposure to the complexities of students, parents, curriculum, assessment and educational accountability. Neither experience makes one profession inherently more resilient than another. The strategic leadership issue arises when somebody moves into a role requiring forms of judgement, commercial awareness, organisational leadership or resilience that their previous professional environment has not systematically required them to practise.

WHY THIS MATTERS FOR RETENTION

This matters enormously to the workforce retention discussion because poorly developed leadership capability creates consequences well beyond the leader themselves. A leader who struggles to delegate creates dependency. A leader who avoids difficult conversations often transfers additional work to reliable people who compensate for underperformance. A leader who cannot prioritise effectively makes everything appear urgent. A leader who lacks confidence in decision-making creates delay followed by unnecessary escalation, while a leader who cannot regulate their own behaviour under pressure can transfer that pressure throughout an entire team. In each case, the leadership capability gap becomes an organisational workload issue for somebody else.

​

The latest Australian Teacher Workforce Data reinforces why this deserves attention. In 2024, 36 per cent of the teacher workforce reported an intention to leave the profession before retirement, with around one in five indicating an intention to leave within five years. Workload, work-life balance and work-related stress remained the three most commonly cited reasons, with each identified by between 69 and 75 per cent of those intending to leave. AITSL appropriately cautions that intention to leave does not translate directly into actual attrition, but the data nevertheless provides compelling evidence that the workforce is experiencing considerable pressure. If leadership behaviour can either reduce or unnecessarily increase organisational friction, then leadership development cannot reasonably sit outside the workforce retention conversation.

IS LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT AN OVERHEAD?

This brings me to what I believe is one of the more difficult questions for boards and executive teams. Schools quite rightly organise themselves around the educational interests of students, and a significant proportion of financial decision-making is understandably evaluated through the lens of student outcomes. The difficulty arises when investment in the leadership capability of staff is interpreted primarily as an overhead rather than as an investment in the system through which student-facing resources are ultimately converted into outcomes. Buildings do not educate students. Budgets do not lead people. Strategic plans do not implement themselves. Every resource a school possesses ultimately relies upon people making thousands of decisions about how those resources will be used.

​

If that is true, leadership development should not be viewed as competing with investment in students. It is one of the mechanisms through which investment in students becomes effective.

​

This is particularly important as people move further into senior and strategic leadership. The capability required to lead a department is not identical to the capability required to lead an executive team, and neither is identical to the capability required to engage effectively with a board, interpret an increasingly complex strategic environment or allocate tens of millions of dollars in organisational resources. If we expect leaders to acquire these capabilities primarily through experience after they have already assumed the responsibility, we should not be surprised when the quality of leadership becomes inconsistent.

HAVE WE BEEN FAIR TO TEACHERS?

Perhaps the system has therefore been somewhat unfair to teachers. We have encouraged accomplished professionals to accept progressively more complex leadership responsibilities, often because they have demonstrated excellence in the work immediately beneath the role, and then relied upon goodwill, experience and personal development to close the capability gap afterwards. Many have done so extraordinarily well. Others have struggled, and the people around them have often absorbed the consequences.

​

The question is not whether teachers have the capacity to become outstanding organisational and strategic leaders. They clearly do.

​

The question is whether we have been deliberate enough in preparing them to become those leaders before asking them to carry the responsibility.

​

If leadership quality has such a significant influence upon culture, workload, wellbeing, retention, resource allocation and strategic performance, perhaps developing leadership capability should no longer be treated as something we attend to when budgets and time permit.

​

Perhaps it is one of the most important investments a school can make.

​

And perhaps the leadership shortage facing schools is not simply a shortage of people willing to lead.

​

It may also be a shortage of organisations that have deliberately built the capability required for people to lead well.

REFERENCES

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2025). Improving induction: Part 2 – school leaders. (AITSL)

​

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2026). ATWD National Trends: Teacher Workforce (June 2026 ed., 2020–2024). (AITSL)

​

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (n.d.). Australian Professional Standards for Middle Leaders. (AITSL)

​

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (n.d.). InSights – Evaluating your Principal Preparation Programs: Research Report. (AITSL)

​

Australian Council for Educational Research. (2024). What is needed to improve teacher professional development initiatives? (ACER India)

bottom of page