BUILDING A SCHOOL GOOD PEOPLE WANT TO STAY IN
The Intrinsic Link Between Strategic Leadership
and Teacher Retention
Stephen Scott, ETHICLEAD Founder and Principal
Why workforce retention should become a strategic leadership responsibility.
There is an understandable temptation when discussing workforce retention to search for a program, initiative or benefit capable of convincing people to stay. Yet retention is rarely determined by one organisational intervention because employees experience organisations as systems. Their decision to remain is influenced by the quality of their work, the behaviour of their leaders, the confidence they have in organisational direction, the fairness with which accountability is exercised, the opportunities they receive to contribute and develop, and whether the demands placed upon them remain sustainable. This is precisely why I believe workforce retention should be considered a strategic leadership responsibility rather than something delegated predominantly to Human Resources.
​
The research provides important context for that proposition. AITSL's latest national data identifies workload, work-related stress and wellbeing, work-life balance and administrative workload as the four most commonly cited reasons among teachers intending to leave before retirement. Parent and student behaviour have also become increasingly significant, both reaching close to half of those intending to leave in 2024. Earlier Australian research similarly found that teachers considering departure described heavy workloads and the emotional toll of their work, while recommending meaningful reductions in workload among the measures worthy of attention. None of this suggests that leadership alone determines retention, and it would be intellectually irresponsible to pretend otherwise. It does, however, suggest that many of the conditions influencing retention intersect directly with decisions leaders make about priorities, resources, organisational systems and the way people are led.
DECIDING WHAT MATTERS AND LEADING WELL
Perhaps the first contribution strategic leadership can make is to become considerably more disciplined about prioritisation. Strategy is not the accumulation of worthy initiatives. It is the resources, and therefore which activities will receive less. This requires leaders to become as comfortable discussing what the school will stop doing as they are discussing what it intends to commence. If every strategic priority is simply layered upon existing activity, the organisation eventually transfers the cost of its inability to prioritise onto its workforce. People compensate through longer hours, increased intensity and continual reprioritisation until the cumulative burden becomes unsustainable.
​
The second contribution is leadership capability itself. Schools cannot build sustainable organisational environments if leadership effectiveness remains dependent upon personality, goodwill or positional authority. Leaders require the capability to delegate appropriately, conduct difficult conversations before problems become entrenched, make decisions at the appropriate level, communicate expectations clearly, hold people accountable consistently and regulate their own behaviour when circumstances become difficult. These disciplines matter to workforce retention because ineffective leadership does not remain confined to the leader. Its consequences are experienced by everybody required to compensate for it.
SHARING THE LOAD AND LETTING GO
The third contribution is organisational capacity. Schools remain vulnerable when effective leadership depends disproportionately upon a handful of highly capable individuals who continually hold the organisation together through extraordinary personal effort. Those people frequently become the very employees the organisation can least afford to lose, yet the system quietly increases its dependency upon them because they are reliable. Sustainable strategic leadership requires the opposite. It develops shared understanding, distributes capability, clarifies decision rights and embeds disciplined organisational practices so that performance becomes progressively less dependent upon individual heroics. This not only strengthens succession; it creates a more sustainable environment for the people currently carrying disproportionate organisational load.
​
Finally, strategically mature organisations continually learn. They do not assume that because a process, meeting, reporting requirement or initiative once created value it should continue indefinitely. They ask whether assumptions remain valid, whether activities continue contributing sufficient value and whether organisational systems can be redesigned to release capacity for higher priorities. This is particularly important in schools because educational organisations accumulate activity extraordinarily well. Programs develop constituencies, processes become traditions and reporting requirements survive long after anyone can clearly articulate the decision they were intended to inform. Without disciplined organisational learning, yesterday's legitimate work quietly becomes today's organisational friction.
A DIFFERENT WORKFORCE QUESTION
Building Strategic Leadership Capability will not solve Australia's teacher workforce shortage, nor should we pretend that it will. Many of the challenges affecting the profession require coordinated policy, funding and societal responses extending well beyond the authority of individual schools. However, Boards, Principals and Executive Teams should not allow the scale of those external challenges to obscure the considerable influence they retain over the organisational conditions experienced by their own people.
​
Perhaps the most useful contribution school leaders can make to workforce retention is therefore not another retention initiative. It may be to create an organisation in which priorities are genuinely prioritised, resources follow strategy, leadership does not unnecessarily create additional work, accountability is fair, difficult issues are addressed before others are required to compensate for them, and people's finite capacity is treated with the same strategic discipline applied to every other scarce organisational resource.
​
Good people will still leave. Careers change, circumstances change and healthy organisations should expect a reasonable degree of workforce movement. The objective should never be retention at any cost.
​
The more important aspiration is to ensure that good people are not choosing to leave because the organisation has made meaningful work unnecessarily difficult to sustain.
​
Perhaps that gives Boards and Executive Teams a more useful workforce question to consider.
​
Rather than asking what more we can offer people to encourage them to stay, what could we stop, change or lead differently so that fewer good people begin wanting to leave in the first place?
THE CONVERSATION CONTINUES
Throughout the first three parts of this discussion, I have argued that workforce retention should not be considered exclusively as a workforce problem. Schools cannot control every factor influencing whether teachers remain in the profession, but Boards, Principals and Executive Teams exercise considerable influence over the organisational conditions within which their people experience their work. Priorities, workload, accountability, decision-making, delegation, organisational friction and the behaviour of leaders themselves can either contribute to an environment in which good people can perform sustainably or gradually make already demanding work unnecessarily more difficult.
​
This places considerable responsibility upon those who lead our schools, but it also raises a question that I believe deserves much closer examination. If leadership capability has such a significant influence upon workload, culture, wellbeing and ultimately workforce retention, how deliberately have we prepared the people we promote into leadership to exercise that responsibility?
​
The pathway into school leadership is unusual. Many of our middle and senior leaders began their careers as excellent teachers before progressively assuming responsibility for teams, departments and eventually whole organisations. Yet the capabilities that made them exceptional teachers are not necessarily the same capabilities required to lead adults, manage performance, allocate resources, navigate organisational complexity or contribute to long-term strategic direction. Too often, we appear to have expected those capabilities to develop through experience after the person has already assumed the responsibility.
​
Perhaps, therefore, there is another dimension to the workforce challenge that warrants our attention. We should certainly continue asking how we create schools in which good teachers want to remain. However, we might also need to ask whether we have invested sufficiently in developing the leaders responsible for creating those schools in the first place.
​
That is where I want to continue the conversation in Part Four:
​
We Have Invested in Great Teachers. Have We Invested Enough in Great Leaders?
​
Why the pathway from classroom excellence to strategic leadership deserves closer examination.
REFERENCES
Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2026). ATWD National Trends: Teacher Workforce (June 2026 ed., 2020–2024).
​
Heffernan, A., Bright, D., Kim, M., Longmuir, F., & Magyar, B. (2022). ‘I cannot sustain the workload and the emotional toll’: Reasons behind Australian teachers’ intentions to leave the profession. Australian Journal of Education, 66(2), 196–209.
​
Longmuir, F., Gallo Cordoba, B., Phillips, M., Allen, K. A., & Moharami, M. (2022). Australian teachers’ perceptions of their work in 2022. Monash University.
