WHEN THE ORGANISATION MAKES THE WORK HARDER
The Intrinsic Link Between Strategic Leadership
and Teacher Retention
Stephen Scott, ETHICLEAD Founder and Principal
Understanding the hidden organisational friction that contributes to workforce fatigue.
There is an important distinction between demanding work and unnecessarily difficult work. Teaching has always been demanding, and contemporary education has undoubtedly increased that complexity through changing student needs, heightened community expectations, regulatory requirements, technological change and increasingly diverse responsibilities placed upon schools. It would therefore be unrealistic to suggest that better leadership can somehow make teaching uncomplicated. Nor should it. Meaningful professional work frequently requires considerable effort, judgement and commitment. The more useful question for leaders is whether all of the effort our people currently expend is actually necessary to achieve the outcomes we expect of them.
​
I describe the unnecessary component as organisational friction. Organisational friction is the additional effort people expend navigating poorly aligned priorities, unclear decisions, duplicated processes, ineffective communication, unresolved performance issues and organisational systems that make legitimate work harder than it needs to be. It is rarely created deliberately and is therefore difficult to see when examining individual processes in isolation. A meeting runs for an hour longer than necessary. An unclear decision requires several people to seek clarification. Two teams unknowingly undertake similar work. A new initiative is introduced without an existing priority being removed. An underperforming employee is allowed to continue because a difficult conversation has been avoided, leaving reliable colleagues to absorb the consequences. None of these events appears particularly significant on its own, yet their cumulative effect can progressively consume extraordinary amounts of organisational capacity.
IT'S NOT JUST THE HOURS, IT'S WHAT FILLS THEM
This matters because workload is not experienced as an abstract number of hours. It is experienced through the quality of those hours. Fifty hours spent undertaking meaningful, well-prioritised work within a supportive and disciplined organisation will not necessarily be experienced in the same way as fifty hours characterised by ambiguity, duplication, rework, unnecessary escalation and continually changing priorities. This does not diminish the significance of excessive working hours; the current Australian data provides ample reason for concern. Rather, it suggests that reducing workload requires more sophisticated thinking than simply attempting to remove tasks. We should also examine the organisational conditions that cause legitimate work to consume more time, attention and emotional energy than should reasonably be necessary.
​
Leadership behaviour has a significant influence upon those conditions. A leader who delegates poorly does not simply increase their own workload; they create dependency that slows decisions and transfers frustration throughout the team. A leader who avoids a difficult performance conversation does not eliminate the problem; they frequently redistribute its consequences to reliable employees who compensate for somebody else's underperformance. A leader who cannot distinguish strategic priorities from operational urgency eventually communicates that everything is important, leaving others to determine what should receive attention. Poor communication creates rework, indecision creates delay followed by urgency, ineffective meetings consume time, inconsistent accountability rewards some people with less work and others with more, while poorly regulated leadership behaviour can transfer the emotional pressure experienced by one person throughout an entire team.
WHERE THE COST OF FRICTION LANDS
These are sometimes discussed as interpersonal leadership issues, yet their consequences are organisational and economic. Every ineffective leadership behaviour consumes capacity somewhere. Someone waits, compensates, clarifies, repeats, escalates, fixes, absorbs or works longer because the organisation failed to operate as effectively as it could have. When this occurs occasionally, capable organisations absorb it. When it becomes habitual, organisational friction begins contributing to Strategic Drag and employees experience that drag personally through increased workload, frustration and reduced confidence that their effort is being used well.
​
This is why I believe workforce retention requires boards and executive teams to look beyond traditional human resource responses. Wellbeing initiatives, recognition programs and employee benefits may be valuable, but they cannot compensate indefinitely for an organisational system that continually manufactures unnecessary work. Indeed, there is a danger that organisations respond to workload by introducing additional wellbeing initiatives that themselves require meetings, administration and participation, inadvertently adding another layer of activity without addressing the organisational conditions creating the original problem.
PRODUCTIVE PRESSURE OR UNPRODUCTIVE FRICTION?
The challenge is therefore not to remove every source of pressure from organisational life. That would be neither possible nor desirable. The challenge is to distinguish between productive pressure, which accompanies meaningful work and ambitious organisational aspirations, and unproductive friction, which consumes people's finite capacity without contributing proportionately to organisational purpose. Strategically capable leaders become increasingly disciplined at recognising that distinction because they understand that people's time, attention and energy are resources every bit as finite as the money contained within the annual budget.
​
This raises an uncomfortable question for leadership teams. If we could somehow calculate the hours our people spend every year compensating for unclear priorities, unnecessary processes, poor delegation, ineffective meetings, avoidable rework and unresolved leadership issues, what would that number look like?
​
More importantly, what does continually asking good people to absorb that friction eventually do to their willingness to stay?
THE CONVERSATION CONTINUES
In Part Three, I want to move beyond diagnosing the problem and consider what schools can actually influence.
​
Strategic leadership cannot eliminate every factor contributing to teacher attrition. It can, however, materially influence many of the organisational conditions through which teachers experience their work.
​
The question therefore becomes less about how we retain people and more about what kind of organisation we are asking them to remain within.
REFERENCES
Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2026). ATWD National Trends: Teacher Workforce (June 2026 ed., 2020–2024).
​
Heffernan, A., Bright, D., Kim, M., Longmuir, F., & Magyar, B. (2022). ‘I cannot sustain the workload and the emotional toll’: Reasons behind Australian teachers’ intentions to leave the profession. Australian Journal of Education, 66(2), 196–209.
