top of page

WHAT IF TEACHER RETENTION IS THE WRONG PROBLEM TO SOLVE?

The Intrinsic Link Between Strategic Leadership
and Teacher Retention

Stephen Scott, ETHICLEAD Founder and Principal

Perhaps we need to look more closely at the organisational conditions that influence whether good people choose to stay.

Australia does not need another article telling school leaders that we have a teacher workforce problem. The evidence has been accumulating for years and, despite considerable attention from governments, systems, professional associations and schools themselves, the challenge remains significant. The latest Australian Teacher Workforce Data released by the Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership (AITSL) reports that 36 per cent of the teacher workforce intended to leave the profession before retirement in 2024, with approximately one in five indicating an intention to leave within the next five years. AITSL appropriately cautions that an intention to leave should not be interpreted as actual attrition, particularly where the intended departure is many years away, but the underlying reasons teachers provide for considering departure remain difficult to ignore. Among those intending to leave before retirement, workload was identified by 75 per cent, work-related stress and wellbeing by 70 per cent, work-life balance by 69 per cent and administrative workload by 65 per cent.

​

These findings are hardly new. Research undertaken by Heffernan, Bright, Kim, Longmuir and Magyar involving 2,444 Australian primary and secondary teachers similarly identified heavy workloads, health and wellbeing concerns and the status of the profession among the factors influencing teachers' intentions to leave. Their research concluded that meaningful workload reduction was among the strategies requiring attention if turnover intentions were to be addressed.

​

Subsequent Monash research involving approximately 5,000 teachers continued to identify workload and administrative burden, safety, respect and the need for teachers to have a meaningful voice among the issues affecting the profession.

ARE WE ASKING THE RIGHT QUESTION?

There is therefore little value in disputing the existence of the problem. What interests me considerably more is whether we are always asking the right question about it. When confronted with a workforce retention challenge, the natural question is to ask what schools can do to retain teachers. We consider remuneration, wellbeing programs, workload reduction initiatives, flexible working arrangements, professional development, career pathways and employee benefits, all of which may have legitimate roles to play. However, I wonder whether our understandable focus upon retaining people can sometimes cause us to begin too far downstream. Perhaps before asking what more we can do to encourage good people to stay, we should examine more closely the organisational conditions that may be causing them to consider leaving.

​

This distinction matters because schools clearly cannot control every factor influencing teacher retention. Individual schools cannot resolve national workforce shortages, change the regulatory environment, independently determine the status society affords the teaching profession or eliminate every complexity associated with contemporary education. What boards, principals and executive teams can influence, however, is the organisational environment within which teachers experience their work. They influence how priorities are established, how resources are allocated, how effectively change is sequenced, how decisions are made, how accountability is exercised, how difficult conversations are conducted, how work is delegated and how much unnecessary complexity employees must navigate simply to perform their legitimate responsibilities. These conditions are not peripheral to the employee experience. They are the employee experience.

WHEN THE ORGANISATION CREATES THE WORK

This becomes particularly important when we consider workload. AITSL reports that full-time classroom teachers across Australian schools worked a median of 50 hours per week during school terms in 2024, while teachers spending greater amounts of time on particular duties were generally more likely to indicate an intention to leave. The relationship was particularly apparent for administration: 34 per cent of teachers undertaking zero to four hours of administrative work per week intended to leave, compared with 48 per cent of those reporting ten or more hours. There is clearly work inherent in teaching that cannot simply be removed, and any serious discussion of workload needs to acknowledge that reality. The more interesting strategic question, however, is how much of the workload experienced within schools is genuinely necessary to achieve the school's educational purpose, and how much is inadvertently created by the way the organisation itself operates.

​

I have become increasingly interested in this distinction because organisations can unintentionally manufacture work. Every new initiative consumes time. Every poorly made decision creates the potential for rework. Every unresolved performance issue eventually transfers additional responsibility to somebody else. Every unclear priority requires people to make their own judgement about what matters most. Every unnecessary meeting consumes a resource that cannot be recovered. Every poorly sequenced change creates additional effort as people attempt to reconcile competing expectations. Individually, these issues may appear relatively insignificant. Collectively, however, they can create an organisational environment in which capable and committed people expend increasing amounts of energy navigating the organisation rather than performing the work for which the organisation actually employs them.

STRATEGY AND THE FINITE CAPACITY OF PEOPLE

This is where the workforce retention conversation begins to intersect with strategic leadership. Strategy is fundamentally concerned with choices about finite resources, yet organisations often apply considerably greater discipline to the allocation of money than they do to the allocation of people's time, attention and organisational energy. A school would rarely approve a significant financial investment without asking whether sufficient resources existed to support it. Yet schools can introduce new initiatives, programs, reporting expectations and improvement priorities without applying the same discipline to the finite capacity of the people expected to deliver them. When nothing is stopped, reduced, reassigned or redesigned to create the necessary capacity, strategy does not prioritise work. It simply accumulates it.

​

Perhaps, then, teacher retention should not be viewed exclusively as a workforce problem. At least part of it may be a strategic leadership problem.

​

And if that proposition has some merit, a different question emerges.

​

Before asking what more we can do to retain our people, what are we currently doing that unnecessarily makes good people question whether they want to stay?

THE CONVERSATION CONTINUES

In Part Two, I want to explore what I describe as organisational friction: the unnecessary effort people expend navigating poorly aligned priorities, unclear decisions, duplicated processes, unresolved issues and organisational systems that make legitimate work harder than it needs to be.

​

Because not all workload is created by the work itself. Sometimes, the organisation creates it.

REFERENCES

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2026). ATWD National Trends: Teacher Workforce (June 2026 ed., 2020–2024).

​

Heffernan, A., Bright, D., Kim, M., Longmuir, F., & Magyar, B. (2022). ‘I cannot sustain the workload and the emotional toll’: Reasons behind Australian teachers’ intentions to leave the profession. Australian Journal of Education, 66(2), 196–209. 

​

Longmuir, F., Gallo Cordoba, B., Phillips, M., Allen, K. A., & Moharami, M. (2022). Australian teachers’ perceptions of their work in 2022. Monash University.

bottom of page